Sunblocks and Sunscreens: Year-Round Advice for Parents
By Claudia Anrig, DC
With an unusually hot summer winding down, many parents have been diligently covering their children with sunblocks and sunscreens for the past several months, believing it is best for their children.But how effective are these products at protecting them from the damaging rays of the sun? And just as important, how safe are the products themselves?
The History of Sun Protection Factor (SPF)
The concept of the "Sun Protection Factor" or "SPF," originally credited to Franz Greiter, supposedly helped determine which sunblock or sunscreen would be best for use based on a measurement of effectiveness when applied at an even rate of 2 milligrams per square centimeter of skin. Controversy still exists over the accuracy of this rating system and whether the rate of application truly represents actual use.1-2 With the more widespread use of sunscreens came the development of waterproof and sweatproof products, and eventually the claim that sunblocks and sunscreens are the ultimate protection against skin cancer.3
While many sunscreens now offer "broad-spectrum" protection against both UV-A and UV-B rays, that wasn't always the case. The original idea to block the UV-B rays that cause sunburn may have been a sound one, but as with most chemical options, it failed to consider the consequences. While sunscreens and sunblocks protected the skin from being burned by UV-B rays, they did not block UV-A rays, which penetrate the skin more deeply and actually cause melanoma.
Moreover, with all sunscreens, but particularly those with higher SPF, the sensation of being burned is stunted, typically resulting in a longer amount of sun exposure, which means more exposure to the harmful UV-A rays that cause melanoma. And to top it off, sunscreens and sunblocks do not allow the body to absorb the sun's rays and produce vitamin D.4
Created to block out the UV-B ray or ultraviolet radiation that causes sunburn, sunscreens were originally designed solely to protect the skin from being burned utilizing different chemicals. These chemicals include oxybenzone, methyl anthranilate, titanium dioxide and zinc oxide, among others.5 Chemicals approved for use within the European Union and other parts of the world that have not been tested include but are not limited to: 4-methylbenzylidene camphor, Tinosorb M and S, Uvasorb HEB and isopentenyl-4-methoxycinnamate.6
Adverse health effects have been associated with some synthetic compounds in sunscreen, and in 2007 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reported a concern regarding oxybenzone (benzophenone-3). There were two studies, the first of which "detected the chemicals in greater than 95% of the 2000 Americans tested,"7 while the second revealed that mothers with high levels of oxybenzone were more likely to give birth to underweight babies.8
Vitamin D and Sunshine
The most powerful and natural vitamin D is produced by the body when in direct sunlight, preferably the noonday sun, for about 10-20 minutes a day or until the skin begins to turn a very light pink. Despite the hype about the sun's rays being dangerous and cancer-causing, the fact is that we cannot be healthy without regulated and regular doses of natural direct sunlight.9
While vitamin D supplements do exist, it's important to differentiate between D2 and D3 forms. The weaker variant is called D2. The most powerful form is D3, and it is this variant that is produced by the body when exposed to sunlight and has been found to be a natural cancer preventative. In 2007, a study published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that vitamin D cut the risk of several types of cancer by as much as 60 percent, but it's important to understand they were using a natural supplement of vitamin D3, which is available in stand-alone dietary supplements.10
Additionally, a 2009 U.K. study reported that "mothers given ten times the usual dose of vitamin D during pregnancy had their risk of premature birth reduced by half and had fewer small babies."8
Internationally recognized research scientist and vitamin D expert, Dr. William Grant, has said that about 2,000-4,000 IU a day of vitamin D can help reduce cancer risk by up to 50 percent. He has also determined that up to 30 percent of all annual cancer deaths could be prevented with higher levels of vitamin D. That equates to 2 million less deaths worldwide and 200,000 less in the U.S. alone.11
Calculate the Recommended Amount of Sun Exposure
Scientists at the Norwegian Institute for Air Research have devised a calculator12 that will estimate how many minutes of exposure you need for your skin to produce 25 mcg (the equivalent of 1,000 International Units) of vitamin D. It is not written for U.S. cities, so you'll need to visitwww.realestate3d.com/gps/latlong.htm to find the latitude and longitude of your city and enter the numbers manually. The easiest way may be to simply Google "altitude of [your town]." Remember to convert it to kilometers. One kilometer is about 3,300 feet.
If your latitude is 39 S, enter -39. If your longitude is 76 W, enter -76. You'll also need to enter the time of day you are going out in the sun, expressed as UTC (Greenwich Mean Time).13 The calculator uses a 24-hour clock, so hours from 1 p.m. to midnight are expressed as 13 to 24.
The calculator also wants to know the thickness of the ozone layer. I suggest just setting this one to medium. Be sure to click the radio button next to the entries. They are often not automatically selected when you fill in the values. Keep in mind that the exposure times given are considered enough to maintain healthy vitamin D status. If you are starting out with a vitamin D deficiency, you might need more.
In 2002, 50 percent of all cancers in the United States were skin cancers. That works out to approximately 1.1 million cases of diagnosed skin cancer in one year. Considering the prevalence of sunscreen "awareness campaigns" over the past 50 years, it's safe to assume that many of those 1.1 million people were wearing sunblock or sunscreen. So, it's equally safe to assume that sunscreen is not the ultimate protection against skin cancer.11
Rather than having parents apply chemicals to their children, we should advocate limiting sun exposure to spans of 10-20 minutes at a time. When limits cannot be set, be sure parents and their children wear loose-fitting, light-colored clothing, as lighter-colored fabrics will reflect the sun's rays instead of absorbing them. Also, hats with a wide brim will protect both the face and the back of the neck. When swimming, always have children wear a thin, light-colored T-shirt over their swimsuits. This will protect their shoulders and chest from overexposure to the sun, as these are the areas most likely to burn when in water.
- "Protecting Your Skin: The History of Sunscreen."www.randomhistory.com/2009/04/28_sunscreen.html
- How OTC Sunscreens Are Formulated. Letter from Edward Kavanaugh, president of The Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association, to Dr. Debra Bowen, deputy director of the FDA Office of Drug Evaluation, Sept. 11, 1998.www.fda.gov/ohrms/dockets/dailys/00/Sep00/090600/c000573_10_Attachment_F.pdf
- Pekkanen J. "Summer Sun Can Kill; The Sun Does to Your Skin What Cigarettes Do to Your Lungs." Chicago Sun-Times, July 17, 1987.
- "How Supermodel Gisele Bundchen 'Infuriated Cancer Experts.'" Mercola.com, April 22, 2011.
- Information on sunblock. University of California, San Francisco, School of Medicine; Department of Dermatology.www.dermatology.ucsf.edu/skincancer/General/prevention/Sunscreen.aspx
- Chemicals in sunscreen as approved by the European Union. Council Directive, 1976. eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/consleg/1976/L/01976L0768-20060809-en.pdf
- Holder E. "CDC Finds 97 Percent of Americans Contaminated by Sunscreens." Naturalnews.com, April 11, 2008. www.naturalnews.com/022990_oxybenzone_sunscreen.html
- Gillie O. "Vitamin D 'May Cut Premature Birth Risk and Protect Newborn Babies." The Sunday Times, Oct. 10, 2009. www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/scotland/article6868729.ece
- "Vitamin a Cancer Fighter? D Supplement Cuts Risk of Disease in New Study." Albany Times Union, 2007.
- "When Should You Go Out in the Sun?" Mercola.com, Sept. 4, 2008.
- "Sunblock Can Actually Increase Your Cancer Risk." Mercola.com, July 2, 2003.
- Calculated Ultraviolet Exposure Levels for a Healthy Vitamin D Status. Norwegian Institute for Air Research, 2005. http://nadir.nilu.no/~olaeng/fastrt/VitD-ez_quartMED.html
- You can convert your time into Greenwich Mean Time by going towww.timeanddate.com/worldclock/converter.html.